Formulation is fine - swipes on nicely. Doesnt last as long as I would like, but maybe thats too be expected for a lipstick. The color is amazing. Its a great MLBB for someone like me whos overall neutral (cool undertones, warm overtones, potential Winter cool?) and pink/purple natural lips. It feels a bit more natural than Charlotte Tilburys pillow talk (see photo for comparison).

It's perfect as an overlip. It's natural and has a different feel depending on what kind of accent color you apply. It's so pretty when you apply a glossy tint. + It's a pity that it doesn't last very long when used as an overlip, but the color is so pretty The tone is 23-24, and the lip color is a bit dark, It feels so natural to me that I didn't apply it, but I like it because it cleans up the tone much better than the one that wasn't applied! Photo - Shell Nude/Smoked Beige/All That Jazz

I think the colors were chosen very well. I always carry it with me when I go out (along with the accent color hehe) My skin is around 23-24, so when I apply smoked beige, it's a bit like a toad So if you apply this color to the edge and apply the accent color in the middle, it's great. Below is a pretty combination + All That Jazz + Wame Gentlebrick (glossy finish) + McChili Photo - Shell Nude/Smoked Beige/All That Jazz

I was influenced. The swatches looked so pretty online I had to buy. Mauve bean on top

The color is really beautiful, but it doesn't suit me very well; by the way, I should mix it with Yekura and other products.